Home / News / Opinion / The Killing of Imam Luqman Abdullah

The Killing of Imam Luqman Abdullah

What is the true story? Law enforcement has drummed up this incident to be terrorism-related, or somehow related to the faith or political views of Imam Luqman and his community. The mainstream media has predictably followed suit. But the actual charges against these 11 individuals say otherwise. The charges mentioned are as follows: possession of body armor and fire arms by a convicted felon, providing firearms to a convicted felon, tampering with a motor vehicle identification number, mail fraud, and selling/receiving stolen goods.

What is the true story?By now, most of us have heard the news of the killing of Imam Luqman Ameen Abdullah by the FBI in Detroit, MI. There are many questions surrounding the death of Imam Luqman. Although I do not have the answers to these questions, there are a few issues that come to mind. 

Yesterday I was able to read the criminal complaint filed in the United States District Court in the Eastern District of Michigan (Case: 2;09-mj-30436) on October 27, 2009. Included in the complaint is a 43-page sworn affidavit by FBI Special Agent Gary Leone. This affidavit chronicles nearly two years of surveillance by the FBI on Imam Luqman and Masjid al-Haqq in Detroit. The complaint discusses terms such as kuffar, Qureish, revolution, Imam Jamil, jihad, hadith, etc. This is odd. The reason this is odd is that these terms have absolutely nothing to do with what the criminal complaint charges the 11 individuals with. 

Law enforcement has drummed up this incident to be terrorism-related, or somehow related to the faith or political views of Imam Luqman and his community. The mainstream media has predictably followed suit. But the actual charges against these 11 individuals say otherwise. The charges mentioned are as follows: possession of body armor and fire arms by a convicted felon, providing firearms to a convicted felon, tampering with a motor vehicle identification number, mail fraud, and selling/receiving stolen goods. There are absolutely no terrorism-related charges in this complaint. There are no charges in any way related to the religious or political views of Imam Luqman. Two years of investigation, and no material support charge, no conspiracy charge, nothing. When asked why Imam Luqman had not been charged with terrorism, the United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan Terrence Berg said, “The charges speak for themselves.” And that is exactly my point.

As often has been the case in these so-called “terrorism” cases, smaller charges are brought and law enforcement still acts as though they brought terrorism-related charges. And the public doesn’t know the difference. We have seen this pattern again and again under the Bush administration, and President Obama has continued this dishonest policy. Look at the words being used in the context of these arrests in the media and the statements given by law enforcement, and ask yourself what they have to do with the charges which are alleged. Why are they saying this is related to terrorism? Do they think we can’t read what they themselves wrote? What does being a Sunni or a fundamentalist or a Muslim have to do with tampering with a motor vehicle identification number?

“O you who believe! If a liar/evil person comes to you with a report, look carefully into it, lest you harm a people in ignorance, then be sorry for what you have done.” (49:6) 

What was the nature of this investigation by the FBI? According to its complaint, at least three agents were used by the FBI in surveillance of Masjid al-Haqq. The complaint stated that these agents constantly said and did things in order to make Imam Luqman or others at the mosque say or do something which would lead to an arrest on terrorism charges. For example, the criminal complaint mentions how one agent told Imam Luqman he is interested in blowing up people during the Super Bowl in Detroit, and Imam Luqman responded that he would not be involved in killing innocent people (see information from confidential source S-2, paragraph 14). This is just one example, and there are many similar examples in the complaint. Obviously this does not come as a surprise, because this is what the FBI does for a living. But we should realize that after two years of this harassment, the best material they could come up with is in their complaint.

This incident is another reminder to the Muslim community. When someone is spending time and effort in order to set us you and put you in prison, they are not your friend. This is not an attempt to thwart a crime. This is an attempt to set your you-know-what up. There is a difference. Any criminal defense attorney will tell you never to speak to law enforcement without an attorney present. Most will tell you that if the FBI comes to speak with you, even with an attorney present, you would be crazy to speak with them. This is because the goal of law enforcement is to get a criminal conviction. It is beyond disappointing that some members of our Muslim community, both Sunni and Shia, know what the FBI is doing to their fellow Muslim brothers and sisters on a daily basis, yet they continue to want to buddy up to these same agents. How many more examples are needed before we open our eyes?

I do not know what all transpired with Imam Luqman and his community. I do not know if they are guilty or innocent of any of the alleged crimes. What I do know is that a man exercised his First Amendment rights, and he did not commit a crime by doing so. Had he committed a crime or a terrorism-related offense, it would be in the complaint. Instead, all we see are regular criminal offenses being alleged. 

Unfortunately there is a segment of our community more interested in looking like the “good Muslim” than in standing up against oppression or finding out the truth. These Uncle Toms have predictably made irresponsible statements regarding Imam Luqman and his mosque without any of us even knowing all the facts. The Muslim community must stay away from these types of organizations and mosques, whose leadership will lead our community away from the sunnah of our Holy Prophet (peace be upon him and his progeny).

Let’s for a minute believe all the allegations in the complaint. Would this justify this man being killed? Would it justify the alleged 18 shots fired at him? Why all the references to Islam in the complaint if he is not charged with any political or terrorism related offenses? Why all this talk about Imam Jamil?

Please, let us open our eyes. 

About Huda Jawad

Check Also

Ask the Shaykh: How do we know whether we will be on Imam Mahdi’s (ajtfs) side?

Editor’s note: The following was originally published by the Ask the Sheikh publication. It has been shared here …

Time Management in the Perspective of the Ahlulbayt and Qur’an, Part III

Editor’s note: Islamic Insights is honored to host a short series on “Time Management” by …

  • djibril husayn

    we think that certain comments and question posed by the author of this article are pertinent to how things are and how they aught to be perceived.
    Being South African, we are from the outside looking in, and as such we perceive a scenario which is simple, yet diabolical. It has become an established fact that the migrant Muslims in AmeriKKKa have become neutralised due to their fear of losing their citizenship and being deported to their counties of origin, therefore they acquiesce to the type of Islam which is consonant with the wishes of the autocratic government.
    On the other hand, the present day African American is the son of the soil and cannot, in anyway, be expelled. This poses a major problem to the autocrats, as the spread of Islam within this society would secure its pertuation for generations to come, and would finally be able to confront them. The only method to try and neutralize this segment of society is: “elimination!”
    It would be to the benefit of the migrant Muslims to put their weight behind, and in conjunction with, the African American Muslim, and confront in a manner, conducive to the teachings of the Glorious and Miraculous Qur’an, the nefarious and diabolical schemes of these autocrats. It is eminent that this happens, because the migrant Muslims will be marginalized and forgotten on the pages of history when Islam ultimately triumphs, as is the promise of Almighty ALLAH (Glorified be HE).

  • S

    Their intention is to extinguish Allah’s Light (by blowing) with their mouths: but Allah will complete (the revelation of) HIS Light, even though the Unbelievers may detest (it).
    O you who believe! You be helpers of Allah: as said Jesus the son of Mary to the Disciples, “Who will be my helpers to (the work of) Allah?” Said the Disciples, “We are Allah’s helpers!” Then a portion of the Children of Israel believed, and a portion disbelieved: but WE gave power to those who believed, against their enemies, and they became the ones that prevailed.
    The life of this world is but play and amusement: and if you believe and guard against evil, HE will grant you your recompense, and will not ask you (to give up) your possessions.
    But if any one earns a fault or a sin and throws it on to one that is innocent, he carries (on himself) (both) a falsehood and a flagrant sin.
    And remember WE took a Covenant from the Children of Israel (to this effect): worship none but Allah; treat with kindness your parents and kindred, and orphans and those in need; speak fair to the people; be steadfast in payer; and practise regular charity. Then you turned back, except a few among you, and you backslide (even now).
    And remember WE took your Covenant (to this effect): shed no blood amongst you, nor turn out your own people from your homes: and this you solemnly ratified, and to this you can bear withness.
    You say: “We believe in Allah, and the revelation given to us, and to Abraham, Isma’il, Isaac, Jacob, and the Tribes, and that given to Moses and Jesus, and that given to (all Prophets) from their Lord: we make no difference between one and another of them: and we bow to Allah (in Islam).”

    United we must stand for the truth no matter who you are. Fear the consequenses of the hereafter if you believe and do good and avoid evil. That is what a TRUE believer does. Stand right for the one religion, the one God from the beginning of time, if you but believe.

  • ~55

    This was terrible news when it hit our community. There are about 40 articles ranging from the national New York Times, to the local pressandguide that talk about this incident and not a single one talks about the facts of the 43 page report. This article is the only one that begins to disect the report for it’s finding. Inshallah the truth will be revealed.

    Hassan A.



  • Jeff

    I understand there are strong emotions on both sides over the details of this unfortunate encounter. The loss of life in any situation is tragic. My question is how can the faith based communities live together in peace. In American we profess freedom of religion and we also seek to protect the U.S. from people who seek to violently overthrow our government. Agreed there is a lot of racial sentiment in the US. but there is a lot of acceptance too. We have a history of persecuting people of color yet the United States have made tremendous strides to provide equal opportunity for all. I have lived and traveled in many countries that do not share the same tolerance for individual rights that are provided in the United States. Those countries spanned Asia, Africa, Europe, North and Central America. I have not intention of changing my Christian beliefs. I was born into the Christian faith, grew up learning Christian teachings, and have matured to learn more about Christ and God. I accept others may have received different teaching from Jews, Catholics, Muslims, Buddhist, Hindus and so on. My intent to to live in peace with all. To live within the laws of my country. I have learned to respect law officials and to react calmly when challenged to stop. If I were to raise a weapon toward law officials I would expect to be fired upon until I could not longer raise a weapon. The problem we will have resolving the truth of this article will remain with the living FBI officials. I didn’t see any mention of other witnesses who could confirm or deny if the Iman raised a weapon toward the FBI officials. I trust the FBI acted appropriately, but when men are involved, I know man is fallible.