Hookah: Myth and Reality

Hookah: Myth and Reality

Safer than cigarettes?Islamic law on this issue is quite complicated. All Hookah smokers are encouraged to investigate the rulings of their respective Religious Authorities (Maraja Taqleed) regarding smoking tobacco, particularly if you are a youth who enjoys Hookah smoking and are relying on your Hookah-addicted friend’s dad’s uncle’s theory that Hookah is far from being prohibited and might actually be a highly recommended act in Islam. Following are the rulings of a few Religious Authorities on this issue.Safer than cigarettes?The growing popularity of Hookah smoking around the world has given rise to an era in which youngsters, and Muslim youth in particular, are openly and carelessly engaging in this cool new activity. The Hookah, also referred to as a Shisha, Nargile, Hubbly-Bubbly, and water-pipe, is currently the most popular form of smoking, with some Hookahs being able to accommodate up to a dozen smokers at once.

When it comes to Muslim youth and the necessity of finding adequate, affordable, and easily accessible leisure activities, there have always been insufficient resources which both satisfy modern society’s definition of “fun” and are also in line with Islamic standards. Therefore, Hookah smoking has become quite “Islamically trendy” recently, with a rising number of not only Muslim youngsters but also Muslim elders engaging frequently in this activity.

In regards to why there is a growing number of Muslim youth smoking Hookah in the West, Aliya Rizvi, 19, of New Zealand said, “As we rule out many Haram activities which today’s non-Muslim youth enjoy doing, such as clubbing, going to concerts, and Friday night parties, being able to smoke Hookah and going to Shisha bars is something which many youth feel is social, fun, and is also not Haram to my knowledge. Many of my friends have Hookahs at home, so it costs them next to nothing to smoke it when they want to.”

However, Islamic law on this issue is much more complicated than that. All Hookah smokers are encouraged to investigate the rulings of their respective Religious Authorities (Maraja Taqleed) regarding smoking tobacco, particularly if you are a youth who enjoys Hookah smoking and are relying on your Hookah-addicted friend’s dad’s uncle’s theory that Hookah is far from being prohibited and might actually be a highly recommended act in Islam. Following are the rulings of a few Religious Authorities on this issue.

According to his website, Ayatollah Nasir Makarem Shirazi states that smoking is absolutely prohibited in any situation. On the other hand, Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Sistani and Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Khamenei both have similar rulings on the issue: there is no problem in smoking per se. However, if one is already smoking or is about to start smoking, then it is prohibited for him/her to do that if there is a probability that serious harm will take place, and it becomes compulsory to quit. The only exception is if quitting will cause even greater harm, in which case it is not compulsory to quit. However, there is no problem in smoking rarely, i.e. to the extent that there would be no probability of harm in the future. (See Ayatollah Sistani’s A Code of Practice for Muslims in the West, #353, and Ayatollah Khamenei’s Practical Laws of Islam, #1390 and #1397.)

So exactly how harmful is it? One contributing factor towards the soaring popularity of the Hookah among the younger generation is the common misconception that because the tobacco passes through water, smoking Hookah is significantly less harmful than smoking cigarettes.

In Dubai, Muhammad Bukhari, 21, believes that Hookah smoking is much less harmful than cigarettes. He said, “We usually smoke the Shisha, as it is not as bad as cigarettes or cigars. We also have the option of smoking the tobacco-free Shisha, which is much better than smoking the tobacco mixture. Smoking Shisha is extremely relaxing, as you can feel the smooth fruit-flavored smoke as you slowly inhale long puffs. I smoke it for about an hour once a week but no more than that.”

Not as bad as cigarettes? According to an article published on the website of the Mayo Clinic, the World Health Organization (WHO) advisory states that because Hookah sessions usually last for around 20-80 minutes and involve longer and harder puffs in comparison to a few minutes with a cigarette, the Hookah smoker actually inhales around 100-200 times more smoke!

A typical online Hookah wholesaler advertises the low-tobacco mixtures and misleadingly describes it as “a special blend of fresh, dark leaves, fruit pulp, honey or molasses, and glycerin. The Shisha is available in a wide variety of flavors, including double apple, strawberry, melon, pineapple, vanilla, pistachio, and rose. This blend contains only 0.5% nicotine and no tar.”

However, a recent investigation into Hookah smoking by the ABC news network in Australia found that such advertisements are extremely deceiving, as all raw tobaccos contain 0% tar. The tar actually forms as a product of combustion at the time when the tobacco is heated. The investigation found that due to the heavy volume of smoke inhaled, Hookah smokers are exposed to 36 times more carcinogenic tar and up to 15 times more carbon monoxide (the same toxic gas that is contained in the exhaust fumes of a car) than a cigarette.

Alongside the tar, there are nicotine particles which form and which mostly remain in the water of the Hookah. However, a certain amount does reach the lungs, and 11 seconds later, it reaches the brain. It has been proven that in the typical tobacco Hookah session, a smoker will consume approximately 1.7 times more nicotine than if (s)he smoked a cigarette. Some other harmful gases which are produced from burning tobacco include nitrosamines, acetaldehyde, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, and various volatile hydrocarbons.

Although the aforementioned are the effects of smoking Hookah with a tobacco mixture, smoking low-tobacco or tobacco-free Hookah does not mean that it is harmless, as many youth believe. Any form of smoke being inhaled is unhealthy for the mind and body. The charcoal and other similar material used to heat the tobacco-free mixtures have their own toxins, metals, and cancer-causing chemicals. Diseases such as tuberculosis and hepatitis can also be transmitted by sharing water-pipes. In comparison to non-smokers, Hookah smokers are five times more likely to suffer lung cancer and gum disease.

A 19-year-old sister said that in addition to being a social activity, Hookah smoking is a dangerous form of stress relief, yet it is nonetheless an adventurous experience. She also said she believes that “the strong tobacco mixed with fruit is smooth to smoke and is something I really like doing, even thought it makes me feel dizzy. I know it’s unhealthy and dangerous if people get addicted to it, but it’s a form of stress relief for me. I don’t do it often and wouldn’t encourage people to do so. It’s important that people understand the Islamic opinion on Hookah smoking and all the health-related issues too.”

The following two tabs change content below.

Islamic Insights

Latest posts by Islamic Insights (see all)

10 Comments

  1. frequent reader
    December 14, 09:44
    It appalls me that so many people think smoking is glamourous or attractive. It is anything but. Smoking is bad for the lungs as well as smelly. I hope less people engage in this habit.
  2. otowi
    December 14, 12:06
    I don't like it either, I think it is gross, and I grew up in a smoking household. I wish people would leave it aside altogether, even just occasionally. What good does it do to smoke?
  3. abSin
    January 05, 20:38
    This article fails to acknowledge the element of water filtration that occurs in hookah smoking, which is absent in other forms of smoking. I would suggest a more complete analysis before publishing an article on a subject that is fairly clear in the manuals of our jurisconsults.
  4. otowi
    January 06, 01:04
    Asalaam Alaaykum wr wb<br /><br /> The water-filtration and extended hose does not filter out the nicotine, tar, cancer-causing chemicals and dangerous heavy metals. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hookah under the Health section for starters.<br /><br />The rulings were posted by the author re: smoking. <br />[quote]According to his website, Ayatollah Nasir Makarem Shirazi states that smoking is absolutely prohibited in any situation. On the other hand, Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Sistani and Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Khamenei both have similar rulings on the issue: there is no problem in smoking per se. However, if one is already smoking or is about to start smoking, then it is prohibited for him/her to do that if there is a probability that serious harm will take place, and it becomes compulsory to quit. The only exception is if quitting will cause even greater harm, in which case it is not compulsory to quit. However, there is no problem in smoking rarely, i.e. to the extent that there would be no probability of harm in the future. (See Ayatollah Sistani's A Code of Practice for Muslims in the West, #353, and Ayatollah Khamenei's Practical Laws of Islam, #1390 and #1397.)[/quote]
  5. Celeste
    January 19, 13:01
    OK everyone is getting far to crazy about th.is, first off, geez there are far worse things in the world, WHy not tackle the increase in alcoholism? Which harms more than just the drinker. And as for Hookah smokers, I'm not a smoker, but gosh I've been in a hookah bar with a few buds, Hookah smoke doesn't leave that nasty smell that cigarette's do, it's actually quiet pleasant, and cig smokers tend to be snobby people to me, as for hookah smokers it's more of a social thing not a "I have to get my nicotine" routine. I don't care about the healthy facts, the truth is everything is bad for you, everything in moderation people, Pepsi is bad for you in large ammount, those crazy Monster drinks, junk food, god, leave hookah alone and let people kill themselves the way they want to.
  6. anonymous
    February 04, 21:01
    There was no mention of religious authority Sayyed Hussein Fadhlullah who actullay says that smoking shisha is haraam
    • omar
      April 08, 01:41
      no one can say anything is haram unless it is specifically mentioned by the prophet or in the quran....until then it can be makrooh...thats it...plus sheesha never even exsited in the time of the prophet or the relvelation of the quran neither was any type of smoking..so that doesnt even make sense of that dude says its haram..
      • Re: Omar
        April 08, 03:49
        The majority of Muslims actually figure out what's halal and haram based on the research of scholars through the science of Ijtihad - they sift through authentic hadith and narrations aswell as the holy Qur'an. That's how these scholars come to conclusions of what is permissible and forbidden. What's Makruh and Mustahab etc. It isn't possible to establish what is halal and haram simply by looking at the Qur'an and a hadith taking them both for face value. <br /><br />Otherwise, how would we know wheather or not eating a Koala is halal? Are you able to determine the answer for this question based on your own research, or would you also turn to a scholar such as Ayotoallah Sistani? :)
      • Nasir
        October 03, 16:42
        I totally agree with you, on the basis of relegion, no one has a right to make a fatwa about whether Hookah is haraam or or not, however from scientific research it is bad for your health and that is what matters, I don;t think smoking Hookah makes you any less Muslim but it does lessens the capacity of your lungs.

Only registered users can comment.