Home / Religion / Clergy Corner / Ask the Experts

Ask the Experts

“If after the occultation of your Qa’im there were not to remain a person from amongst the scholars who: invite towards him (the Imam); guide others to him; defend his religion by the proofs of Allah; rescue the downtrodden servants of Allah from the snares of Satan and his hoards and the traps of the enemies (of the Ahlul Bayt), then there would not remain a single person (on Earth) except that he would have left the religion of Allah. However, these scholars take it upon themselves to be the protectors of the hearts of our downtrodden Shi’a just as the captain of a boat takes control of the lives and safety of those on his ship. Thus, these (scholars – the ‘Ulama) are the best people in the sight of Allah, the Noble and Great.” (Bihar al-Anwar, vol. 2, pg. 6, sec. 8, no. 12)

When was the last time your car broke down? What did you do when you needed a loaf of bread for dinner? When your wisdom teeth were coming out, who did you turn to? Most likely, you did not take your car to your local Muslim butcher for repair, nor did you go to the pharmacy for dinner rolls, nor did you ask your lawyer to remove your teeth. In these and thousands of other daily life experiences, we refer to professionals in a particular field to help us. Even when we fall sick, we may go to our local medi-clinic for a “quick-fix”; however, the doctor may simply give us something to carry us over until we are able to refer to a specialist in the field to accurately diagnose our symptoms.

Being a religion of “nature”, Islam has put a similar practice in place such that once, a man came to one of the Imams and as if to mock him, jokingly said, ‘You claim the Qur’an contains everything – so tell me where does the Qur’an show you how to bake bread!’ The Imam sat silently for a brief moment and then replied, “Read the verse of the Qur’an which states, ‘So then ask those who know if you do not.'” (Suratul Nahl, v. 43) The Imam was alluding to the point that you need to “ask the experts” when it comes to anything and everything in life!

During the time of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his progeny), he was the sole authority in all issues (religious, political, societal, etc.), and all questions about daily life were forwarded to him or one whom he placed in authority – those who had been trained in his ‘school’ of religious understanding. During this era, according to scholars such as the late Ayatollah Shaheed Murtadha Mutahhari and contemporary thinkers like Grand Ayatollah Nasir Makarim Shirazi and Ayatollah Ja’far Subhani, Ijithad was practiced in the open by companions of the Prophet – with his full support and blessings! With his passing away, the chain of his legitimate successors – the 12 Imams – started. The first of the explicitly appointed leaders was the Commander of the Faithful, Ali ibn Abi Talib, and the last rightful successor of the Prophet was the 12th Imam, al-Hujjat ibn al-Hasan al-Askari (peace be upon them all).

The Imamate of the Twelfth Imam was quite different than that of the previous 11 Imams since he was, by the wisdom of Allah, required to go into two separate and distinct occultations. His Minor Occultation lasted for a little over 70 years, during which time he was represented by four specific representatives whose duties were to forward questions on various day to day issues from the Shia to their Imam, collect the various funds (Khums, Zakat, etc.) and distribute them as the Imam saw fit, as well as other important duties.

After the death of the fourth representative in the year 328 AH, the doors of specific representation were closed. However, the guidance did not stop, and according to the directive issued to the Shia in the traditions, we were to follow those Fuqaha (scholars) who: “…guard their soul, protect their religion, follow the commandments of their Master…” and thus, this responsibility has been placed on the shoulders of our scholars whom we refer to as the Maraja Taqleed (lit. “sources of emulation”).

Through this article, we aim to bring to light some of the questions that people have about the basis, scope, jurisdiction, and necessity of the Maraja Taqleed in today’s day and age. Indeed, much more can be said, and there are countless books written on this topic; however, we leave the detailed discussions for another occasion.

Question 1: What is the history of Taqleed? Is this a new phenomenon, or did Taqleed exist in the time of the Infallibles as well? Is there any Qur’anic evidence to support the ‘knowledgeable person guiding the unaware person’?

Answer 1: First off, many verses guide us to ask those who have more knowledge if we do not know. For example, “It is not right that the true believers in Islam all go forth (to fight a defensive battle) – rather, why does not a group from amongst them go forth to become specialists in religious learning, and after completing their studies, return back to their own community and warn them (so that they will have fear of Allah)?” (9:122)

Obviously, we all cannot become experts in the field of Islamic studies – we need artists, doctors, lawyers, engineers, and specialists in all other fields of life, and it is through this verse that we understand that a group of people must go forth to gain a deep understanding of the religion and upon returning from studies and upon the others returning home (from their own vocations or in the case of this verse, the scared defense of Islam), that they learn the religion from those who have gained knowledge on the religion.

In terms of ahadith, ponder upon the following (lengthy) tradition:

It has been narrated from Ahmad b. Ali b. Abi Talib al-Tabarsi in his book al-Ihtijaj from Abu Muhammad al-Askari (peace be upon him) in regards to the words of Allah, The Grand, “So then woe be to those people who write The Book with their own hand and then say to other that this is from Allah.” The Imam (peace be upon him) said, “This verse was in regards to a group of people from amongst the Jews.”

A man said to Imam as-Sadiq (peace be upon him), “If this verse is about a group of people from amongst the Jews who did not know The Book (revealed from Allah) except through hearing it from their Ulama (scholars), how is it possible that they are castigated for following them and for accepting (the statements of) their Ulama? In addition, are not then the common folk from amongst the Jews similar to the common people from amongst us (the Muslims) who follow (perform Taqleed of) their Ulama?”

The Imam (peace be upon him) replied, “Between the common people from amongst us (the Muslims) and the common people of the Jews, there is a stark difference in one respect and also one similar trait in another respect. As for the similar trait that is shared, indeed Allah has also castigated our common people (the Muslims) who blindly follow their scholars just as He castigated the Jews. And as for the difference between the two, the common people amongst the Jews knew that their scholars were prone to openly speak untruths, used to consume what was forbidden for them, used to take bribes, and also used to alter the practical rulings of the faith while their hearts were sent a warning that anyone from amongst them who would perform these acts would be known as an open sinner (Fasiq) and that it was not permitted for him (the scholar from amongst the Jews) to speak the truths about Allah and it was also not permissible for them (such scholars) to act as intermediaries between the creations and Allah and thus because of this, they were castigated. Similarly are the lay (from amongst the Muslims) – if they recognize open and blatant transgressions being performed by their Ulama (scholars), strong forms of discrimination and prejudice and an attraction to the material word – then whoever follows such people (does their Taqleed) will be similar to the Jews whom Allah had castigated as they used to follow the transgressions of their scholars!

As for the Fuqaha who protect their own soul, who safeguard their religion, who go against the desires and passions of their lower desires, and who are obedient to the command of their Master, then it is permissible for the common people to follow them in religious issues (perform Taqleed), and this state is not found except in some of the Fuqaha of the Shia, not all of them.

So then surely those who committed some sins and vulgar acts in a similar way that have been committed by scholars of the general stream (the scholars of the Ahlus Sunnah) – do not accept anything from them that they relate from us nor show them any respect. The mixed messages (ahadith) that been related claiming to be from us (Ahlul Bayt) have increased; therefore, the immoral people take from us and change it completely because of their ignorance, and they put things differently because of their lack of knowledge. Others deliberate to lie about us.”

This tradition makes it clear that Taqleed as we know it today was an issue which the Imams were asked about, and they spoke about it and gave guidance to their followers on the qualities of who could be considered as a Marja.

As for having a Marja during the period of the Imams, there are countless examples given in the book Ijtihad during the Era of the Infallibles written by Muhammad Ridha Jawahiri, which we do not go into here.

Question 2: Who or what is a Mujtahid and a Marja Taqleed, and what qualifications are required for each one?

Answer 2: A Mujtahid can be defined as “One who has reached to a profound depth within his overall awareness of Islam and its foundation such that he is now permitted to conduct research from the four primary sources (Qur’an, Sunnah, consensus [of the past scholars], and intellect) to derive the sacred laws of Islam known as the Shari’ah (daily actions of the faith) which we refer to as our Fiqh.

The teachings of Islam have laid down strict conditions in terms of whom we are to take our legal rulings from; however, it must be clearly noted that none of these are based on any personal bias or preference, as being a Marja is not a “right” given to us by God; rather, it is a “privilege”, and thus, the following traits must be present: male, Twelver Shia, adult, sane, of legitimate birth, living, and just (‘adil). (Each of these traits can be discussed in length as to their exact and precise definition and “why” they are there; however, this article is not the place for such a discussion.)

Once a man or woman has traversed through the rigorous regiment of studies enabling him/her to delve into the Qur’an and Sunnah of the Fourteen Infallibles, they then begin their quest in formulating the code of law which they themselves and the lay are to follow. They continue in this journey for many years until they reach to a level of competency such that amongst their peers, they are recognized as an “authority” in the extraction of the laws of Islam from the sources and, through the push of those around them, are heralded into the limelight as being a Marja Taqleed – a point of reference for the formulation of the laws of Islam according to their understanding of the world around them and the general and specific guidelines found within the Islamic texts.

Whereas anyone (man or woman) can reach to the level of Ijtihad – thus, becoming a Mujtahid (or Mujtahida in the case of a woman) – the status of a Marja Taqleed is something reserved for men [according to the overall consensus of the past and contemporary scholars]. In actuality, gender need not be an issue of contention as the laws are of the Divine, and when it comes to the designing of these laws, a Mujtahid elevates himself such that he does not see man or woman, white or black, Arab or non-Arab – all he sees are servants of Allah, and all he recognizes is the need to help them fulfill their responsibilities by formulating the laws of Islam. We should not think that since the Maraja are men that they formulate laws to make Islam a misogynistic faith – as tomorrow, the same argument could be applied to why all Prophets, Messengers, and Imams were men!

Coming to one of the “contentious issues” – one of the requirements is that we follow what is commonly translated as the “most knowledgeable”. If we accept this interpretation, we have problems as who is in a position to say who is the “most knowledgeable”, since if that individual can distinguish the “most knowledgeable”, then it stands to reason that he himself is the most knowledgeable – and thus, we are thrown into a paradox! Thus, it is best if we state that one of the main conditions of choosing a Marja is to see “who has the best ability to delve into the sources of the faith and has an understanding of the society in general to understand the prevailing situations of the world” to extract and derive laws for the benefit of the servants of Allah.

Thus, in other words, what we are asking the experts to explain to us is who in their opinion has: 1. The greatest grip on the Qur’an and its interpretations; 2. A powerful understanding of all of the traditions of the Infallibles; 3. A comprehensive knowledge of the opinions of the early scholars; and 4. The intellectual aptitude to be able to look at the Quran and Sunnah and the world in general, and with these four sources at his disposal, guide the servants to their responsibility.

Question 3: There is only one Qur’an, and all of the scholars refer to the same corpus of hadith, so then why the difference of opinion? Does this mean that “my” Mar’ja is right, while “his” Mar’ja is wrong?

Answer 3: Indeed not! What we must understand is that when we follow the rulings of the Marja, we are following the orders of the Imam, Prophet, and ultimately Allah. Now, what Allah expects from us is “submission” – and as long as the person whom we are following has been permitted to guide us to submission, we will not be held liable for our actions. In other words, even if the Marja was incorrect in his judgment and understanding, we will not be punished for an action we performed as long as we have based our actions on his understanding. In essence, the Marja “has the right to be wrong”.

The “difference of opinion” comes about due to the fact that each scholar understands the Qur’anic injunctions and traditions in his/her own way; however, we should also note that the differences amongst the Maraja are very small, and these “differences of opinion” should not become an issue amongst the believers such that they hurl insults or accusations against the followers of one Marja over the other!

Question 4: Life in Qom or Najaf is greatly different from what I go through in Toronto, New York, London, or any other major metropolis. How can I be sure that a man living “so far away” knows what I am going through or my own personal struggles and is able to correctly diagnose the problem to offer me a remedy?

Answer 4:We are correct that many of the experiences that we go through in “the West” are alien to those living in “the East”; however ,that does not mean that the scholars whom we follow are out of touch with reality or are not able to guide us. First off, we need to realize that even our own doctor, accountant, and mechanic never have “first-hand” knowledge of what we require from them until we explain our situation to them. They then base their response or remedy to us from what we tell them. If we neglect to tell our mechanic of a certain noise in the engine, he will not be able to correctly repair our car. Or if he does repair it, there are bound to be further issues as he did not go to the root cause – and it is not his job to do so. You give him the symptom, and he does his best to correct the problem. The same goes with our religious scholars – if we meet our Marja or write him an e-mail requesting guidance but are not specific or intentionally seek to hide the facts, he will only be able to offer us a verdict on what to do based on what he knows from US. It is not his job to know the specifics – he gives a general ruling based on what he is told of one’s situation.

We also need to give these individuals more credit than we do – yes, they live in far-off lands; however, they are not cut off from civilization. They still watch the news, read newspapers, surf the Internet, and in addition, have representatives and experts in various fields who are (hopefully) providing data to them on various issues.

Question 5: Today, through globalization and the like, we see “councils” set up to address various issues by bringing together the greatest minds who are well versed in the issues at hand – whether they be economic, social, medical, political, etc. With such a push to “work together” to solve the problems of the modern era, why don’t our Maraja establish a “Council of Maraja” in which each one would specialize in a specific field and then we could refer to that one specialist in fulfilling our responsibilities to our Creator?

Answer 5: This was a topic of discussion brought up by many scholars in the past, most notably the late Ayatollah Shaheed Murtadha Mutahhari and the late Mullah Asghar M.M. Jaffer – who went into great detail in a series of lectures on Marjaiyyah and Taqleed and quoted from various high-ranking scholars. I would suggest that you listen to the three lecture series in English delivered by the late Mullah Asghar M.M. Jaffer ,which can be found online at www.al-mubin.org in the Audio/Video section.

Question 6: Okay, so I accept the fact that I need to enact Taqleed when it comes to religious rulings and that I need to choose the most qualified and knowledgeable Marja from the numerous who are out there today, but is there any historical benefit or advantage in this institution? Why not just “do what I want to do” and hope for the best?

Answer 6: Another sphere of influence and authority which the Marja takes on his shoulders is contained within the political realm. This was seen in Iran in 1979 with the Islamic Revolution, the downfall of the Ba’thist regime of Iraq in 2003, and also in 2006 with the invasion of Lebanon. In regards to Iraq, many people (including top-ranking officials in the US government) thought that they would be able to walk into Iraq and enact their plans as they saw fit – however, they did not take one person into the equation: Grand Ayatollah Sayyid Ali al-Hussaini al-Sistani. Perhaps they assumed that the Religious Authority would not involve himself in the political realm based upon their understanding of Shi’i Islam.

The Christian Science Monitor in their analysis of the situation in Iraq in early 2004 wrote, “When US administrator Paul Bremer was pushing for an Iraqi constitution written by US appointees in the summer of 2003, Sistani issued a religious ruling, or fatwa, saying that only an elected body could write the constitution. The US backed down. In November 2003, when Mr. Bremer was seeking to choose an interim government through appointments and indirect voting, Sistani ruled that only direct elections would do.”

USA Today is quoted as writing, “But as the Bush administration and its Iraqi allies struggle to plot a smooth transition to Iraqi rule, the Iranian-born cleric’s political role is growing and forcing the White House to alter its plans.” Later on in the same article we read, “‘A Shiite Ayatollah cannot be non-political’, says Amatzia Baram, an Iraq expert at the U.S. Institute of Peace in Washington. ‘The Marja (source of emulation, as senior ayatollahs are known) is your guide in every aspect of your life. When the situation is not amenable to be political, they will not be political, but when circumstances change, they will immediately change.'”

Thus, from these two examples, we see that the greatness, freedom, and strength of pure Islam is only maintained by having and strictly following each and every word of the Marja Taqleed. The Marja is not there only to teach us how to physical purify ourselves after using the washroom or how to slaughter an animal to make it permissible for consumption or indeed the method of praying, fasting, performing the Hajj, etc. These are important aspects of life, but they are there to, in essence, “fill in” during the occultation of the Twelfth Imam – the sole authority.

In closing, the institution of Marjaiyyah is one which we should take more time to study about and understand so that we can see how it is benefited us over the past centuries since the occultation of the Twelfth Imam. It is through a review of history and the role that the scholars have played that we will begin to appreciate the blessings bestowed upon us by the Prophet and his Ahlul Bayt (peace be upon all of them) in remaining united and being able to always have answers to questions of day to day life.

About Shaikh Saleem Bhimji

Check Also

After the Reappearance of Imam Mahdi

After the reappearance of Imam Mahdi, how long will it take for him to establish …

Sacrificing for Islam: the Life of Imam Ali

The term sacrifice is defined as the “act of giving up something valued for the …

  • Sarmadi Rizvi

    One of my friends does not believe in taqleed. He put forth this question when I posted the above article in a group on facebook. His question is:

    ‎”It is not right that the true believers in Islam all go forth (to fight a defensive battle) – rather, why does not a group from amongst them go forth to become specialists in religious learning, and after completing their studies, return back to their own community and warn them (so that they will have fear of Allah)?” (9:122)

    How does it justify the Taqleed? It imposes the duty on “Learned ones” to return to their “own community”- It is not with the system of Taqleed !

    • dot

      actually, the verse you’re mentioning is also putting the onus on people following those individuals who are advanced in their studies. This is completely in line with taqleed. 🙂

  • H.J

    ^ What does “own community” even mean? I mean, you can probably claim that Muslims are a community too. Anyway, if your friend wants to play the game of quoting random verses, he should consider the following verses that clearly DEMONSTRATE THAT TAQLEED IS WAJIB:

    “Ask (enquire) from the persons of learning if you do not know.” (Surah Nahal: 43)

    “And follow the man who leads (people) unto Me.” (Surah Luqman: 15)

  • Sarmadi Rizvi

    Thanks for you comments friends!

  • Adil Rizvi

    Mashallah – Our Great Maraja work and struggle is evident and could not be hide in enemies propaganda.
    May Allah protect Ayatollah Sayyid Ali al-Hussaini al-Sistani, Ayatollah Sayyid Ali Khamenei and others.

  • raza

    are the prohet as & the masomeen as NOOr,can you prove it both from hadith and quran.